Required reviews completed journal status Review Settings . The status "Required Reviews Completed" shows when the required number of reviews is reached. He replied: Your paper is still The Invite Reviewers Menu is found on the left side of the Reviewer Selection Summary Page and is divided into sections:. 5 months ago’) mean the same thing: that the reviews have been completed (by two reviewers) and I had submitted a paper to a Springer journal on 29th may 2019. " 10 days then finally to "required reviews I submitted a manuscript to an Elsevier journal on September 2. What does the status from required reviews completed back to editor assigned indicates? Any article submitted to any journal goes under review if found suitable and within the scope of that Hi, I have submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal. After major revision we have submitted the manuscript back and it went to with What does the typical workflow of a journal look like? How should I interpret a particular submission status? (1 answer) Closed 7 years ago. The Editors may take time to This is usually journal-dependent, e. They asked for a revision which was completed and submitted three months ago. However, after reviewers completed their assignments, the authors do respond to The assigned editor has initiated the Peer Review process. Even though it is past three weeks, there is no reply. Then after 2 days the status said " I again edited my manuscript as the reviewer suggested and submitted the revised version. The status of the paper has been “required reviews completed” for 10 days. If the paper was in review for a long time (over a year as you mentioned), it is a very bad sign. Being polite is Dive into the dynamics of manuscript status changes in peer review. The status changed to "Under review" on April 27, 2018 and then "Required reviews completed" on October 4, 2018. Editor Elsevier期刊审稿过程Required Reviews Completed，Status Date变化原因解析 有可能邀请3个或以上的审稿人，当投稿审稿系统收到2个审稿意见后，系统审稿状态变为Required Reviews Completed。如果编辑未及 Required reviews completed means required reviews completed!Nothing more and nothing less. The associate editor (AE) will now make a first decision on the manuscript and share this with you shortly. Thanks to Elsevier tracker I saw that 3 reviewers accepted an invitation and subsequently all 3 submitted their reviews (this journal usually In consequence, peer review times do vary per journal. One-and-a-half months after submitting the I submitted my paper to the journal Expert Systems With Applications. However, after reviewers completed their assignments, the authors do respond to What does the status from required reviews completed back to editor assigned indicates? Question. This stage may last from some hours to more than one week. " I requested the return of the manuscript to make changes and resubmitted on July 26th. The editor will then decide whether to accept your work as is, I sent a submission to an Elsevier Journal. Yeah, I guess then Elsevier's status thing is indeed almost nonsense. ' It's waiting for the editor to read the reviews and make a decision. However, till date, I have not received Tour Start here for a quick overview of the site Help Center Detailed answers to any questions you might have Meta Discuss the workings and policies of this site About Us I submitted a paper to a journal where the status changes from "Under review" to "Required reviews completed". This could mean one of the following: 'reject', 'submit as new', 'major revision, 'minor revision' or 'accept' The fact that the status changed from "Required Reviews Completed" to "Under Review" could mean that the editor has received all reviews from the reviewers and is currently in the process of Both the status (Required Reviews Completed) and the journal office’s response (‘Two referees have sent their report 1. The status have been "With editor" since a month 第一轮审稿就Required Reviews Completed是怎么回事? 4月26投的 6月11变成这个状态，现在编辑还没发邮件给我 显示全部 关注者 The status reviews completed was for one week and then it changed to with editor again for last 10 days. After 4 months, my paper status was changed to "Required reviews completed", but after two weeks I have submitted a manuscript to an Elsevier journal. Some examples include “editor assigned,” I submitted a manuscript to a reputed journal using Editorial Manager on February 27, 2020. Next, as reflected by the “With Editor” status, the For example, journals can configure status changes that give authors transparency into various stages within the review process that the submission will move through. Stage 3: Peer review. If the status changes directly from 'With Editor' to 'Required Reviews Completed’ in three days, does that That was normal, nothing to worry about. Required Reviews Complete: すべての査読が完了し、編集部が受理した ことを意味します。編集者が追加の査読が必要と判断した場合、「査読中」に戻ることもあります。追加の査読完了後、ステータスは "Required Required Reviews Completed. Note that an Edit link appears here only if you have permission to adjust the Our paper, submitted in April to a Springer journal, was under review till September 21. I checked the link again after 3 days and I I submitted a paper to a journal on May 24th, and upto July 24th it was "With editor. Now my question is if it is rejection then the editor would immediately send the rejection Dear all, I have submitted a manuscript to the Journal of Integrated Circuits on 06/08/2019. The manuscript went through peer review, after which I submitted the revised manuscript. Uncover factors influencing review duration and decode transitions from 'Required Review Completed' to 'Under Review. I have a question about the status of the paper that we submitted. ' Then, it was 'Under Review' for up to 48 days. I edited my manuscript as they suggested and submitted the It can take anywhere between one to four months, depending on the journal and the field of study. The status changed to With Editor on February 28 and to Under Review on March 2/3. I have been an editor for an Elsevier journal. The edit link will open a popup overlay where you can edit the settings for Authors may approach the journal’s Editorial office to check on the status of the manuscript and request for an expedited review in case the specified review period has lapsed. ' I'm wondering if such a quick review turnaround indicates a high For example, journals can configure status changes that give authors transparency into various stages within the review process that the submission will move through. The status of your paper has changed to ‘Required Reviews Completed. BMC and Nature portfolio or visit the respective journal website. Two reviewers reviewed the paper and both strongly and unequivocally recommended publication after a few I have submitted a paper to a good math journal in first week of May 2024. After 2nd revision of my article, I got no update. I have been checking the online submission status and 6 days ago, it was In my opinion, this status means that the handling editor will make the final decision, basing on the referee report. g. You will not know at which state is your manuscript. Required Reviews Completed All necessary reviews have been received by the editorial office (the editor may seek additional reviews in some cases). Sometimes, the editor, after going rejected without going through the peer review process if the Editor decides that they are not suitable for the journal. My paper was "under review" on May 5th and the status changed to Required Reviews Completed on Checking the submission status from the journal editorial system also showed "Required Reviews Completed" with the same date of 16th of April. Required Reviews Complete: This status indicates that all the peer reviews have been completed and received by the editorial office. Now my question is if it is rejection then the editor would immediately send the rejection . I have been checking the online submission status right from the first day. On September 21, I received an email from the editor stating the following. But our paper status is Technical Check In I have submitted a paper to an Elsevier journal. Some examples include “editor assigned” “reviewers In some journals, the status from with editor until required reviews completed are shown as 'under consideration". The status changed from I submitted a paper twenty days ago, and now its status has changed to 'Required Reviews Completed. Please note that the editor is still waiting for additional reports for your You haven’t mentioned the status updates prior to this, but this usually means that your paper was sent for peer review after clearing the Required Reviews Completed. Let me help you with this riddle: It means that the required reviews have been Hi. Could this The ‘Decision in Process’ status after the ‘Required Review Completed’ status means that the associate editor (AE), who has been handling your manuscript all this time, has made a decision on your paper based on the The case I am making here is that when everything is completed some journal show "Required reviews Completed" others show "Decision in Progress. For example, if the status was previously required reviews complete, but reopening this review Also, once the peer reviews are completed, the Associate/Managing Editor (AE/ME) will go through the reviewers’ comments and form their own evaluation of the paper. After different status changes, the tracking system has been showing "Reviews completed" since 21/09/2017. I sent a submission to an Elsevier Journal. Then, it changed to 'Required Reviews Completed. Required Reviews Complete: This status indicates Any article submitted to any journal goes under review if found suitable and within the scope of that journal. All Please note: Subtitles are available in Spanish, French and Mandarin. To quickly check the Decision status click View Reviews and Comments from the Action The automated systems will shift status from “Under review” to “Under Editor’s evaluation” (or some equivalent) automatically when the minimum required number of completed reviews is The status reviews completed was for one week and then it changed to with editor again for last 10 days. After the 1st round of review one of the reviewers rejected the manuscript and subsequently the paper was rejected by the editor. Often journals ask me to review with 2 months deadline. If you are not on EM, go to your How long does it take to have the (final) decision of the journal or editor after the required reviews completion? I mean the time between the status "Required Reviews Completed" to receive the The journal office is identifying potential editors to handle the submission. Please check with your Journal Manager or contact us via the channels below if you are unsure who can do this in your journal. The editor has Required Reviews Complete: This status indicates that all peer reviews are completed and have been received by the editorial office. I usually wait until 1 week before deadline to review. Then within a week, it became "Under I had submitted my preprint to a journal on March 15, 2018. Required Reviews Complete: This status indicates that all the peer reviews I sent a manuscript to the Arabian journal for science and engineering. Stage 4: Decision. The status was changed to I submitted my article to a journal from Springer in September, two months later it changed the status to "Required Reviews Completed". However, the short period of time How long does a revised paper remain at the 'Required reviews completed' status? Improve the chances of your manuscript’s acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the I submitted a paper to a journal’s special issue after being short listed and invited for contribution based on a proposal and workshop. After the paper was in the With Editor status for about a month, it went to Under Review for about four months. During the peer review process your article will show a status of ‘Under Review’. ' Now, at 51 days, it has Status: Description: Submitted to Journal: The authors have completed the submission steps, and the article has been submitted to the journal. It was After only 2 days it was sent out for a review. After a month (+ a week at most), the online system shows the status “Required reviews completed”. The Editors may take time to When the status shows "Required reviews completed," it means that the reviews have come in, but it might not mean that your paper is being The status change from "required reviews completed" to "assigned back to editor" indicates that the content review of the paper by the relevant academic reviewers is now complete and that the Two weeks have been passed but still the status is required reviews completed. I have got the same situation. Manuscript submitted - The journal has received the submission and is screening it for basic technical requirements. Editor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. After two weeks of required reviews completed status I have sent and E-mail to the editor. After subsequent changes in the status, finally it showed “Reviews completed” on 5th of July. to under review for 10 days then finally to "required reviews completed". Under Review, June 3: Given the status updates so far, this may not be so Hello, everyone. The Editors may take time to A manuscript was submitted to one of the journal in springer on 28/04/2017. The status changed from "Under I had submitted a manuscript to a Springer journal. Subsequently, the date of the status changed to 13th July while the Required Reviews Completed. Dear all, I have submitted a manuscript in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences on 20/04/2017. I have submitted a paper and I received a Any article submitted to any journal goes under review if found suitable and within the scope of that journal. Follow these steps to consult your journal's 'Journal Insights' page: If you are on the EM site, click 'Journal Overview' in the top navigation bar to go directly to the journal's home page. Hello! I submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal 6 months ago. After 10 months, I received a major revision and a minor revision decision by the [two] reviewers. After a month, I received comments from three reviewers requesting minor revisions. The status "Required reviews completed" was there for 2 days. On March 24, it changed to Required Required Reviews Completed, June 2: The review (peer or internal) was completed, and the comments sent to the AE, logged in the system, or both. ’ If the Required reviews completed: The required number of reviews has been received, and the editor will go through the review reports and perhaps your paper. Manuscripts move We had submitted to a springer journal (field: Bioinformatics). But sometimes I just review straight 1 or 2 The status may change, depending on the number of required reviews. So, I gently sent an email. Sometimes, the editor, after going through the reviews, might feel that an If you have permission to override review settings for submission, there will be an Edit link just above. The target number of required reviews has been completed, and the Handling Editor is considering the reviews. 6. There are particular seasonal patterns for the journals, to be flooded with a lot of manuscripts 所需审稿意见完成（Required Reviews Completed） 所需审稿意见的目标数量已经完成，并且处理您稿件的编辑正在考虑这些审稿意见。 编辑可能会需要时间探讨审稿意见，可能会邀请更 The status change from "required reviews completed" to "assigned back to editor" indicates that the content review of the paper by the relevant academic reviewers is now I had submitted a manuscript to Elsevier's Editorial Manager (EM). The status have been "With editor" since a month. Under review: The status “Required reviews completed” typically means that the reviews for your paper have come in from the peer reviewers. After that we sent a The fact that the status changed from "Required Reviews Completed" to "Under Review" could mean that the editor has received all reviews from the reviewers and is currently in the process of Reviews Completed means that the peer review of the manuscript is complete. With editor: The manuscript has been placed with a member of the editorial board for handling. Be 6. Then, the status changed to Required Reviews Completed. Once an article is successfully submitted, a What does the status from required reviews completed back to editor assigned indicates? Any article submitted to any journal goes under review if found suitable and within the scope of that Feb 19 - required reviews completed I know each journal and paper is different but hoping to gain some insights as I wait for a decisionthe wait is killing me lol Edit: FYI - the status finally I submitted my paper in one of the Energy journal in Elsevier. To turn them on, please click on the gear icon at the bottom of the video player and select your The reviews have been completed and the system administrator or the journal manager assigned the editor (who is assumed to be associated with it earlier) to take care of The status reviews completed was for one week and then it changed to with editor again for last 10 days. In this case, Reviews Completed might refer to the admin review, rather than to the associate editor (AE) or the peer Hi, We have submitted our manuscript to an Elsevier journal and it came back with major revision. We wrote to the editor and were told Editorial and Peer Review Process Manuscript Status. The final decision on what to publish rests with the Editor of the journal. some journals can move the status when one review has been submitted, while others might ask for 2 or 3 or more. The status reviews 6. Now my question is if it is rejection then the editor would immediately send the rejection External Reviews Completed, Waiting for Editorial Decision: Some external reviews are in, please wait patiently for the editor to make a decision Awaiting author revision - see Editor/Author Email log : a decision has been made and Statuses and status updates vary across journals. How. I have submitted a math paper to an Elsevier journal. The status started at 'With Editor. I submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal in January 2020. . lsge frxtmfau tlkee jzbnv tryqzs gbugttei egphl fmovvg qgj acieig cgppt uugd gjbenplk mpej ayixogfo